Most people’s first wine auction is not their first foray into wine. Perhaps they have a cellar or maybe the intention of starting one. They have opinions about producers and vintages; they’re ready to dive deeper. Yet, for most, what they haven’t done is sit in a room where a wine they have wanted for years is sold in a matter of seconds.
The auction room is where a unicorn bottle travels from one cellar to another. Maybe it’s mature vintages that left retail shelves two decades ago, maybe a rare large format that was never made in quantity. It could be cases from single cellars that have not moved since the day they were delivered directly from the producer. If you want to drink a wine with twenty years on it, you can wait twenty years while it ages in your own cellar or you can go to an auction.
Ahead of our live sale on December 10th and 11th, I put the beginner’s questions to two colleagues at opposite ends of the same job. Charles Antin, Zachys' Head of Auction, has been calling auctions for most of his career. Ame Brewster, a Senior Wine Specialist at Zachys, spent years as a sommelier and managing a winery before joining the rostrum, which means she knows these wines from the cellar and the table as well as from the catalog.
How to Read a Wine Auction Catalog
The catalog goes live well before the paddle does and for good reason. Almost all of the useful information lives there rather than in the room. An auction lot reveals more than it appears: format, bottle count, fill levels, the condition of labels and capsules, and whether the wine came out of one cellar or was assembled from several sources. That is, provenance is the most valuable line in any description and the easiest to skim past. Should you have any questions, call a specialist before you bid.
How to Research an Auction Lot Before You Bid
Q: Ame, can you take us through your own preparation? How do you study an auction lot, how do you decide what you’re bidding on, and what do you do before a sale that a first timer wouldn’t think to do?
A: First, I love an auction catalogue! It's one of the best resources for a person who wants to learn about wine. It's a quick primer on who's who of fine & rare wine and the subjective AND objective value of producers and vineyards. Zachys always produces an online catalogue for its live-streamed sales, so it's important to know how they are organized to find your way. Catalogues are usually organized by consignment (by individual collection). Up front, I want to know how the collector sourced the wine (provenance) and how the collection was stored. Usually, this information is explained at the beginning of the consignment listing. Within a consignment listing, wines are organized by region and then by producer. Zachys offers an index in the catalogue that lists all the places in the catalogue where a certain producer and wine can be found. There might be multiple consignors offering Screaming Eagle 2023, which allows you to compare lots, bid strategically, and possibly amass multiple bottles. Once you have narrowed down the lot or lots that interest you, it's time to read the fine print. DON'T skimp on this step. You need to be sure that you are bidding on a 750ML or a 6L, that you know if the wine comes in packaging such as the original wooden container (OWC), and any external conditions that would impact your interest in the wine. Everyone is buying for different reasons, so if your goal is to have a show cellar, you might want a near-pristine label. If you are buying to consume the wine (like me), then you might care less about aesthetics and more about price.
Are Wine Auctions Only for Serious Collectors?
Q: Charles, what does a first-timer most often get wrong before they ever walk into the room?
A: The misconception that most people have about auctions is they're for "other people." Maybe it's a stereotype of a dirty ancient cellar in Downton Abbey or billionaires bidding on $10,000 bottles. But the simple reality is that we offer a wide array of wines starting around $50, and from all of the world's wine regions. So, if you're only drinking contemporary release wines, you're missing out on a lot of pleasure by not bidding at auction.
Why Provenance, Ullage, and Bottle Condition Matter
Q: Ame, you’ve opened more old bottles than most people ever will. What do fill levels and capsules tell you that a catalog note can’t if you’re someone who’s never ventured into old wine before?
A: The good news is that a catalogue note will tell you the fills levels and capsule conditions! The other good news is that a serious auction house, like Zachys, will vet the collection before bringing it to sale. Trusting your auction house is key. All that said, wine is a "living" product, so every bottle will have a slightly distinct character due in part to its journey since harvest. We can glean some clues to the quality of the wine by considering the fill (ullage) and other external characteristics. As wines age, they naturally lose some ullage. Even wines stored in perfect cellar conditions will have lower ullage over time. It is expected that a wine over 50 years old will have a lower ullage than one that is 20 years old. A savvy buyer should use their judgement when buying a wine with a lower ullage. The best approach? Look at a photo of the wine as the color of the wine will tell you even more than the ullage. I've personally tasted many a bottle with a lower fill and outstanding quality. The same is true for wines that show signs of old seepage (remnants of wine having seeped out of the bottle). While this can sometimes be an indication of an improperly stored wine, it can also just be an indication of a producer who overfills their bottles (looking at you, Lalou Bize Leroy). If the color of the wine is glorious and the fill is not too low for the vintage, I am confident bidding on the wine.
Wine Auction Estimates, Reserves, and Buyer’s Premium
Every lot carries a low and a high estimate, which represent the specialists’ analysis of current auction market data pertaining to that specific lot. Some lots end up clearing the high estimate; others quietly sell under the low estimate. Both outcomes usually come down to condition, provenance, the strength of the consignment, whether the wine is in its original wooden case, and the market on the day.
Behind the estimate sits a reserve, which is the confidential minimum the consignor will accept. It is generally set at or below the low estimate. A lot that fails to reach the reserve goes unsold. You will never be told what a reserve is, which is the point of it.
The number that catches first-timers is the buyer’s premium. The hammer price is not the price. A premium is added on top, and then, depending on where you are and where the wine is going, sales tax, shipping, and storage. Somebody who sets a limit of five thousand dollars and bids five thousand dollars has not spent five thousand dollars.
How Buyer’s Premium Affects Your Bidding Budget
Q: Charles, can you explain the buyer’s premium to someone who has never bought at auction, and how it should change the number they write down as their limit? How would you approach your first auction with a strict budget with BP in mind?
A: There are a few main differences to buying at auction vs. Retail, and these elements really hold true across various categories (art, watches, jewels etc.). The first is that the auction house's margin is called the "buyer's premium." When you place a bid either online, or by raising a paddle in the room, that's called the "hammer price," and it's usually a nice, convenient round number. Every auction house has slightly different "increments" but in general, they're by $50s to $1000, by $100s to $2000, by $200s to $5000 and so on. So, say you place a bid of $1000 and win. Your invoice will be for $1000 (which goes to the owner of the wine, the consignor) plus the "buyer's premium," which for wine is usually about 25%. When you buy a bottle of wine at retail, or a sandwich for that matter, you just get a single price: $10 for pastrami on rye. They don't break down the shop's margin for you. If you think that's a lot, the auction house has a lot of expenses that come out of that: storing, inspecting the wine, the catalog, packing it on site and so on. When you set a budget, simply back out the 25%. So if your budget is $1250, you should only raise your paddle up to $1000. And remember, Zachys sells wine based in the state of DE, which means you don't need to factor in the ~9% sales tax of certain auction houses.
What to Expect at a Live Wine Auction
Live sales move faster than people expect, partly because there’s a ton of wine to go through, and partly because the room is often lively. It’s easy to become distracted. The lot before yours is not when you want to be working out how the auction functions.
Register in advance and collect your paddle early. Bidding rises in increments which the auctioneer sets and announces. The guest is never naming a figure; they are accepting the next one. Raise the paddle clearly and hold it up until you are out; a half-raised paddle is an invitation to be missed. Lots run in catalog order, so you can time your arrival, though the pace varies. It is always worth being in your seat several lots early.
Absentee Bids and Phone Bidding
If any of that sounds like more pressure than you want on a first outing, do not do it. Leave an absentee bid at your maximum and let the book bid on your behalf. Otherwise, arrange a phone line and have somebody in the room hold the paddle while you listen. Nobody will think less of you for it.
Understanding the Rhythm of a Live Sale
Q: Charles, does a sale have a rhythm? Do lots early in the session behave differently from lots at the end, and should that change when a beginner bids?
A: Everyone should experience a live, commercial wine auction at least once. They're different than fundraising wine auctions, and different from other categories, too. Zachys pioneered the idea that a wine auction should be fun, way back in 2002 or so. Since then, Zachys auctions are events at top restaurants (Cafe Carmellini, Ai Fiori, Daniel, The Grill and so on) where you can have lunch, BYO, and bid on a few lots. They're lively. That said—especially if you plan on hanging out for a long time—they can be a bit too lively. So you should for sure come in with a plan on what you'd like to bid on. In general, we try to put the most valuable, rarest lots mid day.
What the Auctioneer Sees From the Rostrum
Q: Ame, you came to this from the restaurant floor and now you’re on the rostrum. What can you see from up there that bidders don’t realize is visible?
A: I can still play Somm to some degree at the rostrum, using my years of wine service, wine knowledge, and sales skills to convey the "cool factor" or "opportunity" an auction lot offers. From the rostrum, I can see what all online bidders see, but I can also see how many people are online and, in the room, showing interest in that particular lot. I know most of our buyers' habits and wine passions, so I can use my professional judgement to "anonymously" but intentionally steer buyers to make certain good judgements on when to bid. I like to use the word "opportunity" when I auctioneer to bring buyers' attention to an underappreciated lot, a wine that I believe deserves more attention, either because the bid is too low for the wine's market "worth" or because the wine is insanely cool and deserves a bidding frenzy (get it while you can). I also have the experience of having tasted so many of the fine & rare wines that we sell, so I can champion these great wines from a place of experience. I hope that my own passion for these wines gets everyone else excited too!
What to Buy at Your First Wine Auction
In the excitement of your first live auction, it would be worth bidding on something you’d like to open rather than lay down. Drinking wine teaches you more than holding it does, and a bottle opened in February will tell you more about whether auction buying suits you than a case that sits untouched for a decade. Drinking the bottle may even direct your next auction purchase.
Beyond that, the value in a live sale tends to sit slightly off the famous names. The marquee lots attract the most attention and the most competitive bidding. The categories that run quieter are where a first-timer with a modest budget can do genuinely well.
Where to Find Value at a Wine Auction
Q: Charles, where is the genuine value in a live sale right now? What’s underbought?
A: One of the benefits of selling with Zachys is that we have so many ways to sell wine—retail, live sales, online sales. So our live auctions tend to focus on the best of the best. However, when we sell a collection in its entirety, oftentimes wines sneak in that maybe aren't the absolute upper echelon, and that's where you can find some good value. I still see cases of ~30 year old Diamond Creek come up for a song (don't tell).
Why You Should Have a Bidding Plan
Q: Ame, somebody walks in with a few thousand dollars and no real plan. Where should they look in a catalog like the one on Dec. 10-11th, and what are they most likely to overpay for?
A: First, have a plan. Take an hour before the sale to read through the catalogue. If you don't, you will spend your $1000 early on and wish you had waited for a better opportunity or a more compelling wine. If you truly can't plan ahead, buy Champagne. NYE is right around the corner, and everyone loves Champagne. You won't ever regret buying Champagne. -- What are you most likely to overpay for? Anything you fall in love with, get competitive over, or have an emotional connection to. However, I don't ever think it's "overpaying" if the wine brings you joy. Wine is incredibly subjective – if it makes you happy, then it's worth it!
How to Know When to Stop Bidding
Which brings us to the only part of this that is genuinely difficult, and the part no guide can solve for you.
Q: For both of you, how do you stop yourself chasing a lot past your limit? And is there ever a good reason to?
Charles: No, there is no reason to stop. The heart wants what it wants. This is like saying, "how do you stop loving your spouse, and should you."
Ame: It depends on the lot and my reason for wanting it. If it's a wine that's difficult to find, then I am inclined to bid much higher, knowing that I may not see it again (Ledru is a good example). If it's a wine that is more abundant, I research recent auction hammers and retail prices. I never want to pay more at auction than at retail for wine, unless the wine is really special (direct from the (de Rothschild) Piatigorsky cellar, for example). So, I calculate my potential bid plus the buyer's premium to see how high I am comfortable going. Much of the wine at auction cannot be found at retail, so this only works for certain wines. I will also bid much higher on a pristine lot with amazing provenance, but so will everyone else, so get your high absentee bids in early. Ultimately, a truly rare wine that holds personal meaning to you is worth what you can afford and are willing to pay for it. Only you can do that math!
What Happens After You Win at a Wine Auction
Winning your desired lots is the fast part; the coordination and time to get you your wine can feel slow after the excitement. Invoices issue after the sale and payment is due within a set window; wine is released once it clears. From there you either collect in person, have it shipped to an address that can legally receive it, or leave it in professional storage, which is often the sensible choice if you are buying more than you can house properly. Shipping can be seasonal, since nobody moves wine through a July heatwave or a January freeze if they can help it, so a December purchase may sit until spring. That is normal and it is better for the wine.
Davis A. Steller | Published: November 13, 2026